|
Post by steveinthecity on Jul 20, 2019 11:55:26 GMT -8
Survivor Game test incorporating new rule Overview
(from Ditch's template) A list of comic book artists is posted. For our trial game each artist will start with 4 points. When you post, you either vote for (+) or against (-) an artist. When an artist has zero points they're knocked off the list until only one artist's name remains. The person who initially posted the last standing artist is the winner, but I think it's fair for any members to vote an artist up or down because the more the merrier. Rules- You are eligible to post only after at least two other members have posted before you. example: Sue / Sam / Sally post consecutively, so Sue or players other than Sam or Sally could make the next post. The aim is to avoid a stalemate that would result from a Sally/Sue/Sally/Sue/Sally/Sue run of posts. - Copy the list from the most recent post (remember to delete the previous poster's (+) or (-)). - Add one point, or subtract one point from an artist. Add a (+) or (-) at the end to show what you did. - Bold the artist name to make it easy for everyone to see your action. - There is a 7 point max per artist with each artist starting with 4 points. Quickening the pace of the game shouldn't affect the final results in this instance. - When an artist has no points left, they're removed from the list with the next post.
|
|
|
Post by steveinthecity on Jul 20, 2019 11:57:30 GMT -8
Sergio Aragones 4 John Buscema 4 Howard Chaykin 4 Robert Crumb 4 Bill Finger 4 Frank Frazetta 4 Russ Heath 4 Gil Kane 4 Rob Liefeld 4 Frank Miller 4 Mike Ploog 4 Humberto Ramos 4 Bill Sienkiewicz 4 Jim Steranko 4 Alex Toth 4 Barry Windsor-Smith 4 Wallace Wood 4 Bernie Wrightson +5
|
|
|
Post by Bats on Jul 20, 2019 12:11:43 GMT -8
Sergio Aragones 4 John Buscema 4 Howard Chaykin 4 Robert Crumb 4 Bill Finger 4 Frank Frazetta 4 Russ Heath 4 Gil Kane 4 Rob Liefeld 4 Frank Miller 3- Mike Ploog 4 Humberto Ramos 4 Bill Sienkiewicz 4 Jim Steranko 4 Alex Toth 4 Barry Windsor-Smith 4 Wallace Wood 4 Bernie Wrightson 5
|
|
|
Post by Bats on Jul 20, 2019 14:43:08 GMT -8
|
|
|
Post by Ditch Fahrenheit on Jul 20, 2019 15:08:37 GMT -8
Sergio Aragones 4 John Buscema 4 Howard Chaykin 4 Robert Crumb 4 Bill Finger 4 Frank Frazetta 4 Russ Heath 4 Gil Kane 4 Rob Liefeld 4 Frank Miller 3 Mike Ploog 4 Humberto Ramos 4 Bill Sienkiewicz 4 Jim Steranko 4 Alex Toth 4 Barry Windsor-Smith 5+ Wallace Wood 4 Bernie Wrightson 5
|
|
|
Post by steveinthecity on Jul 20, 2019 15:13:52 GMT -8
Sergio Aragones 4 John Buscema 4 Howard Chaykin 4 Robert Crumb 4 Bill Finger 4 Frank Frazetta 4 Russ Heath 4 Gil Kane 4 Rob Liefeld 4 Frank Miller 3 Mike Ploog 4 Humberto Ramos 3 - Bill Sienkiewicz 4 Jim Steranko 4 Alex Toth 4 Barry Windsor-Smith 5 Wallace Wood 4 Bernie Wrightson 5
|
|
|
Post by Bats on Jul 21, 2019 0:02:24 GMT -8
This is going to be a slow game with only 3 people playing. Is everyone aware of this thread?
Sergio Aragones 4 John Buscema 4 Howard Chaykin 4 Robert Crumb 4 Bill Finger 4 Frank Frazetta 4 Russ Heath 4 Gil Kane 4 Rob Liefeld 4 Frank Miller 2- Mike Ploog 4 Humberto Ramos 3 Bill Sienkiewicz 4 Jim Steranko 4 Alex Toth 4 Barry Windsor-Smith 5 Wallace Wood 4 Bernie Wrightson 5
|
|
|
Post by 50 Fiddy on Jul 21, 2019 10:21:07 GMT -8
Sergio Aragones 4 John Buscema 4 Howard Chaykin 4 Robert Crumb 4 Bill Finger 4 Frank Frazetta 4 Russ Heath 4 Gil Kane 4 Rob Liefeld 4 Frank Miller 1- Mike Ploog 4 Humberto Ramos 3 Bill Sienkiewicz 4 Jim Steranko 4 Alex Toth 4 Barry Windsor-Smith 5 Wallace Wood 4 Bernie Wrightson 5
|
|
|
Post by Ditch Fahrenheit on Jul 21, 2019 11:21:18 GMT -8
Sergio Aragones 4 John Buscema 4 Howard Chaykin 4 Robert Crumb 4 Bill Finger 4 Frank Frazetta 5+ Russ Heath 4 Gil Kane 4 Rob Liefeld 4 Frank Miller 1 Mike Ploog 4 Humberto Ramos 3 Bill Sienkiewicz 4 Jim Steranko 4 Alex Toth 4 Barry Windsor-Smith 5 Wallace Wood 4 Bernie Wrightson 5
|
|
|
Post by Bats on Jul 21, 2019 12:24:19 GMT -8
Sergio Aragones 4 John Buscema 4 Howard Chaykin 4 Robert Crumb 4 Bill Finger 4 Frank Frazetta 5 Russ Heath 4 Gil Kane 4 Rob Liefeld 4 Frank Miller 0- Mike Ploog 4 Humberto Ramos 3 Bill Sienkiewicz 4 Jim Steranko 4 Alex Toth 4 Barry Windsor-Smith 5 Wallace Wood 4 Bernie Wrightson 5
|
|
|
Post by 50 Fiddy on Jul 21, 2019 12:58:19 GMT -8
Sergio Aragones 4 John Buscema 4 Howard Chaykin 4 Robert Crumb 4 Bill Finger 4 Frank Frazetta 5 Russ Heath 4 Gil Kane 4 Rob Liefeld 4 Mike Ploog 4 Humberto Ramos 3 Bill Sienkiewicz 4 Jim Steranko 4 Alex Toth 4 Barry Windsor-Smith 5 Wallace Wood 5+ Bernie Wrightson 5
|
|
|
Post by Ditch Fahrenheit on Jul 21, 2019 18:09:56 GMT -8
Sergio Aragones 4 John Buscema 4 Howard Chaykin 4 Robert Crumb 4 Bill Finger 5+ Frank Frazetta 5 Russ Heath 4 Gil Kane 4 Rob Liefeld 4 Mike Ploog 4 Humberto Ramos 3 Bill Sienkiewicz 4 Jim Steranko 4 Alex Toth 4 Barry Windsor-Smith 5 Wallace Wood 5 Bernie Wrightson 5
|
|
|
Post by 50 Fiddy on Jul 21, 2019 18:32:47 GMT -8
Sergio Aragones 4 John Buscema 4 Howard Chaykin 4 Robert Crumb 4 Bill Finger 5 Frank Frazetta 5 Russ Heath 4 Gil Kane 4 Rob Liefeld 4 Mike Ploog 4 Humberto Ramos 3 Bill Sienkiewicz 4 Jim Steranko 4 Alex Toth 4 Barry Windsor-Smith 5 Wallace Wood 5 Bernie Wrightson 6+
|
|
|
Post by Bats on Jul 21, 2019 21:45:59 GMT -8
Sergio Aragones 4 John Buscema 4 Howard Chaykin 4 Robert Crumb 4 Bill Finger 5 Frank Frazetta 5 Russ Heath 4 Gil Kane 4 Rob Liefeld 3- Mike Ploog 4 Humberto Ramos 3 Bill Sienkiewicz 4 Jim Steranko 4 Alex Toth 4 Barry Windsor-Smith 5 Wallace Wood 5 Bernie Wrightson 6
|
|
|
Post by Ditch Fahrenheit on Jul 22, 2019 9:16:24 GMT -8
Sergio Aragones 4 John Buscema 4 Howard Chaykin 4 Robert Crumb 4 Bill Finger 5 Frank Frazetta 5 Russ Heath 4 Gil Kane 4 Rob Liefeld 3 Mike Ploog 4 Humberto Ramos 3 Bill Sienkiewicz 4 Jim Steranko 4 Alex Toth 4 Barry Windsor-Smith 6+ Wallace Wood 5 Bernie Wrightson 6
|
|